Our verdict: The Modkat XL was Luna’s first litter box, and Irene has used it every day for three years. It stopped litter tracking and has never leaked. It costs far more than a plastic box, and the fabric liners hold odor, so plan on washing the liner every day or two. Buy it if tracking is your main problem and your cat is a healthy adult up to about 14 inches long from nose to tail base.
Tested Irene Smith has used this box at home with Luna, her white Persian, since 2023. Read how we test.
Modkat XL at a Glance

A tall litter box with a swiveling lid that you set up for top entry or front entry. The base is one seamless piece, and a reusable liner hooks onto the rim so the plastic stays clean.
In three years with Luna I have had no litter tracking and no leaks. It is expensive, and the fabric liners hold odor, so they need a good scrub.
Irene Smith, owner of Luna
- Size21 x 16.3 x 17 in
- Fits cats up toAbout 14 in long
- EntryTop or front
- WeightAbout 9 lb
- Lid holdsUp to 30 lb
- Price$$$
Pros
- No litter tracking in 3 years with a long haired cat
- No leaks thanks to the seamless base
- Works as top entry or front entry
- Hook on liner makes full litter changes quick
Cons
- Costs several times more than a plastic box
- Liners hold odor, so Irene washes them every day or two
- Too small for big cats
- Replacement liners are an ongoing cost
What Is the Modkat XL?
The Modkat XL is the large version of Modkat’s lidded litter box. It has a tall plastic base with no seams and a lid that swivels into three positions. You pick the setup:
- Top entry: your cat jumps in through a 10.25 inch hole in the lid and climbs out over the grooved lid.
- Front entry: your cat walks in through a door in the side, 6.25 inches off the floor, and steps out onto a small walk off platform.
The box ships with parts for both setups: a top entrance cover, a front entrance cover, the walk off platform, a hanging scoop and two reusable liners, one for each setup (Type C for top entry, Type D for front entry).
Our 3 Year Test With Luna
Irene bought the Modkat XL as Luna’s first litter box and has used it every day since. Luna is a white Persian, which makes this a hard test for any box: long fur picks up litter and carries it out of the box and across the floor.

Irene has used the front entry setup from day one and has never switched to top entry, so everything below comes from three years of front entry use.
Litter Tracking: The Main Reason to Buy It
Irene has had no litter tracking in three years. Two parts of the design do the work. Luna steps out of the door onto the grey walk off step, which is covered in grooves, so litter falls off her paws right at the box instead of riding across the floor. The walls are tall, so litter kicked up while digging hits plastic instead of your floor.
Leaks: None in 3 Years
The base is one molded piece that runs the full height of the box, with no joint between a tray and a hood. Urine has nowhere to escape, even when a cat pees close to the wall. Irene has had no leaks.
Odor and the Liners: The Weak Spot
The reusable liners keep the plastic clean, but the fabric holds odor. To keep the box fresh, Irene washes the liner every day or every second day. That is more work than most owners expect from a premium box. Modkat says each liner lasts up to three months before it needs replacing, depending on how many cats use the box and how much they dig.
Tip: keep a second liner. While one is washed and drying, the other stays in the box, so you never put litter into a damp liner.
Getting Used to It: About Two Weeks
Luna needed around two weeks before she used the Modkat XL with confidence. That is normal for a box with walls and a lid. If your cat is switching from an open tray, keep the old box nearby during the first weeks and remove it only once your cat uses the new one every time.
Price: Expect to Pay More
The Modkat XL costs several times more than a basic plastic box, and replacement liners add to that over time. You pay for the design and the lack of mess. If tracking does not bother you, a cheaper box will do the same job.
Top Entry or Front Entry: Which Setup to Use
| Top entry | Front entry | |
|---|---|---|
| Opening | 10.25 in hole in the lid | 8.3 x 9.8 in door, 6.25 in off the floor |
| Liner | Type C | Type D |
| Best for | Cats that kick litter, homes with dogs | Cats that dislike jumping, older cats |
| Tracking | Lowest by design (not tested by us) | None in Irene’s 3 years of use |
| Our experience | Not tested | 3 years with Luna |
| Watch out for | A jump in and out every visit | Dogs can reach the door |
Start with the setup that matches your cat now. You can switch later, which makes the box useful as your cat gets older and jumping gets harder. Irene chose front entry for Luna and has stayed with it.
How to Set Up and Clean the Modkat XL
- Choose the setup and fit the matching entrance cover.
- Hook the liner onto the rim of the base. Use Type C for top entry and Type D for front entry.
- Add litter and set the lid in place. Irene uses an unscented, fine grain clumping clay litter made from bentonite. Fine, unscented litter is soft on paws and clumps firmly, so it lifts out cleanly with the scoop.
- Hang the scoop on the side so it is always at hand.
- Scoop daily. Swivel the lid open and scoop from above.
- Change all the litter by unhooking the liner, tipping the litter into a trash bag, then washing and drying the liner before you put it back.
Is the Modkat XL Big Enough for Your Cat?
Feline vets recommend a box at least 1.5 times your cat’s length, measured from the nose to the base of the tail, according to the AAHA and AAFP feline guidelines. At 21 inches long, the Modkat XL fits that rule for cats up to about 14 inches.
For a longer cat, see our best litter boxes for large cats, or use the calculator in our litter box size guide.
Modkat XL vs IRIS USA Large Top Entry
| Modkat XL | IRIS USA Large Top Entry | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $$$ | $ |
| Size | 21 x 16.3 x 17 in | 20.75 x 16.1 x 14.6 in |
| Entry | Top or front | Top only |
| Liners | Reusable, hook on | None |
| Base | Seamless, full height | Plastic tub |
| Tested by us | Yes, 3 years | No, researched |
Both boxes cut tracking with a grooved lid. The IRIS costs a fraction of the price but has no liner system and only one setup. The Modkat XL wins if you want a box that adapts as your cat ages and stays clean underneath. See both in our best cat litter boxes roundup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Modkat XL worth the money?
If litter tracking is your main problem, yes. Irene has had no tracking and no leaks in three years with a long haired Persian. If tracking does not bother you, a cheaper box does the same basic job.
How often should you wash the Modkat XL liner?
Irene washes the liner every day or every second day, because the fabric holds odor. Modkat says each liner lasts up to three months before you need a new one, depending on the number of cats and how much they dig.
What litter works best in the Modkat XL?
Irene uses an unscented, fine grain clumping clay litter made from bentonite, and it has worked well with Luna for three years. Fine clumping litter forms firm clumps that are easy to scoop through the open lid.
How long does it take a cat to get used to the Modkat XL?
Luna took around two weeks. Keep your old box nearby while your cat adjusts and remove it once your cat uses the Modkat XL every time.
Is the Modkat XL good for big cats?
Only up to about 14 inches from nose to tail base. Larger cats need a box at least 1.5 times their length. See our picks for large cats.
Can senior cats use the Modkat XL?
Use the front entry setup. The door sits 6.25 inches off the floor, so most older cats can step in without jumping. Cats with severe arthritis may need a box with a 3 inch entry.
Does the Modkat XL keep dogs out?
In the top entry setup, most dogs cannot reach inside. In the front entry setup, the side door is open, so a small dog can still get in.
How much weight can the Modkat XL lid hold?
Up to 30 pounds, so your cat can stand on the lid without damaging it.
More options: 6 best cat litter boxes and all cat product reviews.





